Regulatory language: "Evidence satisfying criterion x under the EB-1A regulatory framework." — 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(x)
Specific documented evidence — see recent remanded cases for patterns that satisfied officers on appeal
Generic praise without specifics — letters without concrete examples of impact routinely fail
Officers cannot add requirements beyond the regulation.
An experienced French film and TV director won his EB-1A appeal after the AAO found he met three evidentiary criteria —
A Filipino guitarist's EB-1A petition was dismissed because, although he met three initial criteria, he could not show s
A musician and music producer's EB-1A appeal was sustained after the AAO found he met four extraordinary ability criteri
A music producer appealing a denial of his EB-1A extraordinary ability petition had his appeal dismissed. Although he me
The AAO remanded an EB-1A petition by a theatrical producer after finding the Director's final merits analysis was incom
A Chinese actress's EB-1A petition was dismissed after the AAO found that meeting three evidentiary criteria was not eno
An EB-1A petition filed by a songwriter, musician, and producer was dismissed after the AAO found he met only two of the
See all 127 criterion x cases →